A gang of petty criminals is paid to break into a remote house and steal a single VHS tape. Inside they find a dead man in front of a wall of TV screens and a pile of unlabeled cassettes - and every tape they play shows a new nightmare: a bachelor party that picks up the wrong girl, a honeymoon couple filmed in their motel room at night, a trip into the woods with a killer that can't be caught on camera, a video chat with a girl who is sure her apartment is haunted, and a Halloween party at the wrong house.